The short answer
When deciding whether to hire a lawyer after a car accident, official sources suggest considering the severity of injuries, who is at fault, and whether you can agree with an insurance company on the value of your claim.

When to Consider Legal Help After an Accident
The American Bar Association (ABA) suggests that nearly everyone agrees people should talk with a lawyer about major life events or changes. This can include being involved in a serious accident that causes personal injury or property damage. Other examples the ABA lists are being arrested for a crime, being served legal papers in a civil lawsuit, changes in family status like divorce or adoption, or changes in financial status such as gaining or losing valuable property or filing for bankruptcy.
According to the California courts’ self-help guide, a lawyer can help in any case. However, they note that talking to a lawyer is especially important if your injury is severe or long-term, if the possible damages are large, if it is unclear who is at fault, or if several people or businesses might be responsible. The California courts also mention that if you have insurance, you can talk to your insurance company. Your insurance might pay some costs, so you might not need to sue, or you might only sue for what your insurance does not cover.
The North Carolina Department of Insurance states that if you are injured in an auto accident, Medical Payments coverage, if you purchased it, might help with doctor and hospital bills, regardless of who was at fault. Bodily injury claims can include doctor and hospital bills, laboratory fees, lost wages, and pain and suffering directly from the accident. North Carolina’s General Statutes do not set guidelines for calculating pain and suffering. So, if you and the insurance company cannot agree on the value of your claim, you may wish to seek legal advice.
What a Lawyer Does in an Injury Claim
The ABA’s public education guide explains that lawyers settle most personal injury cases through negotiations with insurance companies. These types of cases rarely require a trial in court. Settling a case before trial usually requires less legal work.
If a personal injury lawsuit is filed, the person who was injured becomes the plaintiff. The person who caused the injury becomes the defendant. Lawyers for each side, and for the insurer, typically start gathering facts. This is done through an exchange of documents, written questions called interrogatories, or questions asked in person and answered under oath, called depositions. This entire process is known as discovery. After discovery, many cases are settled before they go to trial.
Settling a case means agreeing to accept money. In return, you drop the legal action against the person who caused the injury. The injured person signs a release, which is a document that frees the other side from any further legal responsibility. The ABA guide says that a lawyer can give you a realistic idea of whether a lawsuit based on your claim would be successful. This can help you decide whether to accept a settlement offer. A settlement can happen at any point in a lawsuit, even before a trial or after a trial but before a jury makes a decision. The ABA emphasizes that the decision to accept a settlement offer is always the client’s, not the lawyer’s.
How Lawyers Are Paid
Many personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis. The Legal Information Institute at Cornell Law School explains that in this type of arrangement, lawyers receive a percentage of the money their client receives if they win or settle the case. Generally, the lawyer is paid only if they successfully represent the client. The amount often depends on the final result and at what stage of the legal process the dispute is settled. Contingency fees are very common in personal injury cases, where a successful lawyer is often awarded between 20% to 50% of the money recovered.
The ABA points out that if a case settles easily and quickly, or before a lawsuit is even filed, a client might be able to negotiate a lower percentage for the lawyer’s fee. This would be part of the agreement made with the lawyer beforehand.
Lawyer Licensing
In the United States, rules for lawyer admissions, professional conduct, and lawyer discipline are set by each state or jurisdiction. The National Conference of Bar Examiners explains that a law license from one U.S. jurisdiction is not automatically recognized or transferable to another. To provide legal services in a specific state, a lawyer must be licensed by that state or otherwise authorized to practice there.
Steps You Can Take After an Accident
If you have been in a car accident, you can take steps to organize your information:
- Consider all losses: Think about all the ways the injury has affected you. This can include medical bills, wages you have lost from not working, the need for ongoing treatment, any emotional harm, and potential future problems caused by the injury.
- Gather evidence: Keep anything that supports your side of what happened and your losses. This might include photos of the accident scene or your injuries, medical bills, doctor’s reports, statements from witnesses, and police reports.
- Keep records: Make copies of all papers, note down dates of important conversations or events, and write down the names of people you speak with about the accident or your claim.
When to get legal help
Laws and rules about car accidents and personal injury claims can vary significantly from state to state. If you have questions about your specific situation or need advice on how the law applies to your case, you should talk to a licensed attorney in your state. You can also reach out to a legal aid office or your state bar for further information.
Sources
- American Bar Association, Division for Public Education, When You Need a Lawyer: Are there specific cases when I should see a lawyer? (checked 2026-09-30)
- Judicial Branch of California, California Courts Self-Help Guide, Personal injury cases (checked 2026-09-30)
- North Carolina Department of Insurance, After an Accident (checked 2026-09-29)
- American Bar Association, Division for Public Education, When You Need a Lawyer: Legal Fees and Expenses (contingent fee arrangements and settlement) (checked 2026-09-30)
- American Bar Association, Division for Public Education, Personal Injury Claims: What happens if I file a lawsuit? (checked 2026-09-30)
- American Bar Association, Division for Public Education, Personal Injury Claims: What does it mean to settle a case? (checked 2026-09-30)
- Legal Information Institute (Cornell Law School), Contingency fee (checked 2026-09-29)
- National Conference of Bar Examiners, The Bar Examiner: Background Information About the U.S. System for Regulating Legal Services (checked 2026-09-25)
How this guide was made: it was written with the help of AI and automatically checked against the sources above before publishing. It is general legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by state. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed attorney in your state or a legal aid office.



