YourLawyerGuide

Workers' Comp Claim Denied: How Appeals Generally Work, and What to Know About Hiring a Lawyer

If your workers' compensation claim is denied, you may be able to appeal. The process varies significantly by state and for federal workers.

A man in a green shirt and gray pants sits on a wooden park bench, holding a large brown envelope.
AI-generated photo illustration

The short answer

When your workers’ compensation claim is denied, it means your employer or their insurance company disputes that your injury or illness is work-related, or disagrees with other parts of your claim. Each state has its own system for reviewing these denied claims, and federal employees follow a different process.

Video preview: Workers' Comp Claim Denied: How Appeals Generally Work, and What to Know About Hiring a Lawyer
Watch this guide as a 1-minute video. The YouTube player loads only when you press play.

Who Handles Workers’ Compensation Claims

Workers’ compensation systems are set up differently depending on who your employer is. The U.S. Department of Labor states that its Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs (OWCP) manages four main disability compensation programs. These programs are for federal workers, their dependents, and other specific groups who get hurt at work or develop an occupational disease. These programs provide money for lost wages, medical care, job training, and other benefits. If you work for a private company or a state or local government agency and get injured on the job, the Department of Labor advises you to contact your state’s workers’ compensation board.

How State Appeals Generally Work: Examples from New York and California

Each state has its own specific rules and procedures for handling disputed workers’ compensation claims. Here are examples from two states:

New York State

In New York, the Workers’ Compensation Board states that if your employer or their insurance company disputes your claim, you will not receive cash benefits until a Workers’ Compensation Law judge makes a decision. If you are not getting benefits because your employer or carrier argues your injury is not job-related, you might be able to get disability benefits during this time. However, any payments you receive from the Disability Program will be reduced from any future workers’ compensation awards.

Most claims in New York are accepted and paid without problems, according to the Workers’ Compensation Board. But when disagreements come up, such as whether an injury is work-related, how severe your disability is, the amount of money you should receive, or what medical care is right, the Board is responsible for solving these issues. If the issues are complicated, they go to a formal hearing before a Workers’ Compensation Law judge (WCLJ). At these hearings, the judge may need to hear from you and other witnesses. You can attend virtual hearings online. The Board says that all decisions and awards made by a WCLJ can be appealed. You can ask for an administrative review within a time set by the Board. A panel of three Board members will then review the case and issue a written decision. You can also ask the full Board to review that decision. If you are still not satisfied, you can appeal a panel decision, a denial of full Board review, or a full Board decision to the Appellate Division, Third Department.

California

In California, if your claim is denied or you do not receive all the benefits you think you should, the Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC) offers help. Its Information and Assistance (I&A) officers can answer your questions, provide neutral help, and explain your rights and how to file a claim with a local office of the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB). The DWC says the WCAB is a special court that hears and decides disputed workers’ compensation claims. It has less formal procedures than other courts. Evidence is usually presented through medical reports and sworn testimony. The decision made by a workers’ compensation judge is legally binding on everyone involved.

To start a case in California, you file an Application for Adjudication of Claim form, and there is no fee to file it. The law sets time limits for filing a claim, and if a claim is not filed on time, it may be lost. If you are not happy with the judge’s decision, the DWC says you have the right to ask the WCAB for reconsideration within a certain time limit. A panel of three WCAB commissioners reviews this request. They can confirm the original decision or grant reconsideration. If you are still unhappy with the Board’s decision, you can go to the Court of Appeal and, finally, to the California Supreme Court. The DWC also notes that no settlement or agreement is valid unless a workers’ compensation judge or the WCAB reviews and approves it.

Federal Employees’ Compensation Act (FECA)

The Department of Labor’s regulations explain that the Federal Employees’ Compensation Act (FECA) provides workers’ compensation benefits to civilian officers and employees of all branches of the U.S. Government. It also covers certain other groups who provide services to the federal government, such as Peace Corps volunteers. FECA benefits include money for lost wages, medical and related benefits, and job training services for conditions that result from injuries sustained while performing duties. The Department of Labor regulation states that proceedings under FECA are not adversarial, meaning they are not like a traditional court battle.

If you are a federal employee and your claim is denied, the Department of Labor’s FECA regulation outlines three ways to have a formal decision from the Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs (OWCP) reviewed:

  1. Reconsideration: You can ask the district office to reconsider its decision.
  2. Hearing: You can request a hearing before an OWCP hearing representative.
  3. Appeal: You can appeal the decision to the Employees’ Compensation Appeals Board (ECAB).

The regulation also notes that each of these review methods has time limits and other rules that may apply, and not all options are available for every decision.

What to Know About Hiring a Lawyer or Representative

You have the right to have a lawyer or representative help you with your workers’ compensation claim. The rules for how these professionals are paid vary by system.

  • New York: The New York Workers’ Compensation Board says you can choose an attorney or a licensed representative. The Board licenses non-attorneys to represent claimants in workers’ compensation claims. These licensed representatives must pass an exam on the Workers’ Compensation Law and Board rules. In New York, your attorney or licensed representative cannot charge you directly for their work. If you receive a money award in your case, the representative can ask for a legal fee. This fee must be approved by the Board. Any approved legal fee is taken out of your award and paid directly to your attorney or licensed representative by the insurance carrier.
  • California: The California Division of Workers’ Compensation states that you have the right to be represented by an attorney or representative of your choice. In California, no attorney or representative can charge you a fee for their services unless a workers’ compensation judge approves that fee. An approved attorney’s fee is deducted from the amount you are awarded and paid directly to the attorney or representative by the employer or its insurance carrier.
  • FECA (Federal Employees): The Department of Labor’s FECA regulation states that a representative can charge you a fee and other costs for representing you before the Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs (OWCP). You are solely responsible for paying this fee, and OWCP does not pay for it. Contingency fees, which are fees paid only if you win your case, are not allowed in any form under FECA. Before any fee for services can be collected, the Secretary of Labor must approve it. However, administrative costs like mailing, copying, and travel do not need to be approved first.

Steps to Take if Your Claim is Denied

If your workers’ compensation claim is denied, you generally have options to dispute that decision. Here are some general steps you might consider:

  • Understand the Reason: Find out exactly why your claim was denied. The denial letter should explain this.
  • Gather Information: Collect all documents related to your injury, medical treatment, and employment. This includes medical records, accident reports, and any communications with your employer or their insurance carrier.
  • Review Your State’s Process: Look into the specific steps for appealing a denied claim in your state or under the federal program that applies to you. Each system has its own forms, deadlines, and procedures.
  • Keep Records: Maintain a detailed record of all communications, documents, and deadlines related to your claim and any appeal process.

Workers’ compensation laws and appeal processes can be complex and vary significantly by state and for federal employees. If your workers’ compensation claim has been denied, you may want to speak with a licensed attorney in your state who focuses on workers’ compensation law. They can explain the specific laws that apply to your situation, help you understand your options, and guide you through the process. You can also reach out to a legal aid office in your area or contact your state bar association for resources.

Sources

How this guide was made: it was written with the help of AI and automatically checked against the sources above before publishing. It is general legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by state. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed attorney in your state or a legal aid office.

More in Work and pay

All work and pay guides